Showing posts with label Aaron Rodgers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Aaron Rodgers. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

Collection of Random Thoughts

If you thought the Super Bowl ads, as a whole, were beyond terrible, you’re not alone.

Considering the recent piece for Norman Einstein’s, the chatter regarding the slate of advertisements during Super Bowl XLV has been entertaining to say the least.

Super Sunday has created this expectation that these spots exist for entertainment purposes only. Many companies that participate in the fun follow this line of thinking because they can actually afford to. Coca-Cola and Pepsi aren’t mom-and-pop shops looking to get exposure. Some do it for the sake of doing so, despite beating that drum one too many times (GoDaddy has managed to overuse the premise that sex sells). Yet, the main problem with Super Bowl spots is that they miss out in the basic principle of advertising; tell potential consumers why you matter.

It’s as if companies get hypnotized, then speared by Terry Tate year after year after year.


Remember him?

The Terry Tate ads were hysterical; a linebacker laying out office employees with vicious tackles and talking smack afterwards (surely an unsportsmanlike conduct penalty in today’s NFL). They were the rage of water coolers, Chipotles and college classrooms in 2003.

And you probably couldn’t remember which company was advertised (it was Reebok). As great as those ads were, they failed miserably when it came to what’s called brand recall. Brand recall is where observers of an advertisement are asked to try to provide the maker of the product or service. According to Interactive Advertising Group (now Nielsen IAG), which measures advertising effectiveness, at the time they stated that Terry Tate rated rather poorly in the metric.

Why does this matter to you? The truth is that Super Bowl ads, while great for exposure, are rarely effective in convincing you to purchase an offering. What makes this worse is that companies are so desperate for ‘buzz’ that their ad copy (essentially, scripts) and casting reflect more about entertainment and less about relating to the consumer they want to entice.

Consider that for Super Bowl XLVI (46).
  • Speaking of the Super Bowl, Congratulations to the Green Bay Packers, their fans and owners of any WWE replica championship belt & Aaron Rodgers jersey. You’re all winners. Even better than this is that someone else believes what I posted two years ago about the Quarterback Heavyweight Champion I call GB Punk.

  • College basketball aficionados: you may be aware that I don’t follow the NCAA hardwood as much as I used to. However, you know obnoxious folks like me exist: I want to know who should I pay attention to in terms of potential players in the NBA?

  • Some suggested reading: there may not be a whole lot of fans based on ratings, but if you’re looking for insights on the underrated FX program, Lights Out, take a look at “There’s No ‘I’ in Blog” where Friend of Scribe, Patrick Truby has done episodic reviews since the show began last month. I think it’s a solid show, but even in the DVR era, the biggest issue for its future is the time slot. It's pretty competitive on Tuesdays at 10PM.

  • If you’re still wondering, “C’Mon Man” will never be lived down. That’s perfectly fine with this Scribe since one of his favorite writers, Yahoo! Sports’ Michael Silver recently discovered who that “Dude from Study Hall” was. Nothing but win, as the kids say.

  • Finally, as with many of you, life happens. It doesn’t get in the way of work so much as it has a way of prioritizing it. Sincerest apologies, but your support of this hustle is surely appreciated. Spread the word on Facebook, Twitter and Tumblr.

Friday, September 4, 2009

Look-a-like (II)

As someone who constantly gets "you look like someone I know" or "you look just like (insert popular black guy on TV with glasses)", I can relate to being tired of hearing about who I remind someone of, especially if it's of someone that you aren't particularly fond of.

With that said, sometimes, I can't help but to think the same way. A few months back, you had the first Look-a-like post where Blake Griffin just seemed like he's been here before. I said first because the latest installment is something that I mentioned on Twitter to Emmitt Jones of Sports Business Digest. How the readers of Scribe were not blessed with this for so long is beyond me and I'm the one who thought of it!

So, without further adieu...

Why does Aaron Rodgers, the Green Bay Packers signal-caller (who is going to blow up this season, for sure)...


remind me of another guy whose star has exploded some over the past 18 months... CM Punk.


Maybe it's the photo, but even without the long hair now, I'm still going to call him GB Punk. Hope if he ever comes across this, take it as a compliment since both have found tremendous success over the past year+. Google them and you'll see. They're just twins to me.

Yes, and you're wondering "what's with Jason and the WWE?"

"Oh, you didn't know?!?!"

Friday, April 3, 2009

Follow

Before anything else, let it be known that while it's been a rather challenging two-week period, it has been worthwhile in many aspects.

Without going too deep into a non-sports topic, I have walked away from my recent civil service with a greater respect and understanding of the judicial system. Jury duty is a nuisance as it is a forced interruption into twelve independent and relatively unconnected lives.

It requires that each participant does more than just show up and collect a check, though there have been people who have done just that.

It requires that each participant consider more than the physical and verbal evidence (read back of testimony, for example), but to consider the intangible evidence such as body language and the words left unsaid.

Most importantly, it requires that no matter what prejudices and experiences each juror has with the legal system, (s)he must be as open-minded and fair towards both sides of a conflict.

Trying to meet all of those tasks is easier for some than others. It is admittedly a challenge that is far easier in theory than in practice, yet I can say that regardless of the outcome, myself and my fellow jurors made the best efforts. That’s all anyone – the judge, prosecution, defense or the citizens themselves – can ask for.

And now, for the topic du jour.


It’s supposed to have been an important (albeit, rainy) day in New York baseball history as both new stadiums will be unveiled to the public for the first time with their primary tenants. After batting practice, testing the dirt and signing some autographs last night at the new Yankee Stadium, Derek Jeter talked to the media about his first impressions about the park. He also talked a bit about the anticipation of the Stadium’s first, being that he was the first to get a hit – a home run, apparently – in the building.

Yet, as asked by my editor, an article for this week’s New York Beacon (75 cents at select newsstands in New York City) discusses when he might get his last hit in pinstripes.
The likelihood that Jeter will be anything other than a Yankee – at least to this writer – is nil, unless one of two things happen. Either the team decides to show financial restraint and somehow decides to offer him an incentive-laden deal or the team believes that they can use a stronger arm on the left side of the infield. Yet, considering that Jeter is the Joe DiMaggio of this Yankee era both on and off the diamond, a divorce such as this could be far more embarrassing and heart-attack inducing to the fans than the Joe Torre debacle of 2007, the Billy Martin firings and George Steinbrenner’s feud with Dave Winfield combined.

Or maybe everyone will come to grips with the inevitable; there’s going to be a new guy between second and third some day. The question isn’t who so much as it is a question of when.

The Jeter Watch started recently as he will be a free agent after next season; a 35-year old shortstop whose defensive abilities have been criticized nonstop for a number of years, while his Hall of Fame offense will compel some team outside of the northeast corridor to make an obscenely rich contract offer.

While writing the Beacon piece, I couldn’t help but to think of how hard it’s going to be for the first After Jeter shortstop.

In fact, I couldn’t help but to conjure up the name Pete Myers.

If you can’t remember that name, Chicago Bulls fans might help you. He was the starting shooting guard after Michael Jordan retired in 1993. Myers wasn’t a bad player at all, he just wasn’t Mike.

Now, this isn’t saying that Jeter, whose marketability has grown over the past few seasons, is in the realm of Mike. Yet, at least within a team has storied as the Yankees, his eventual departure will cast a rather large shadow over those who will follow him.

This isn’t anything new. You can’t expect a franchise to suddenly fold when one of its most revered players (if not the most) calls it a career. However, when certain players walk away from the games, you can only hope that the fan base and management they leave behind are rather patient and welcoming.

Otherwise, you have an unsettling period as endured last spring and summer in Green Bay.

Sunday, August 10, 2008

Grounded

The question has been asked in every direction. As much as the Olympics – for better or worse – deserve more attention on this space, keeping up with familiar sports and learning some rarely viewed ones is a daunting task that many others have valiantly taken on (some rather well). And so despite what the caption below the new photo asks (and a general reluctance to discuss too much from the New York area), here’s the answer to the Question of the Year of the Moment.

Brett Favre’s arrival to the Meadowlands has given excitement to the New York Jets’ fan base, the metro area media (what a shock) and anyone who has a major financial investment in the franchise. The future Hall of Famer forced himself back into the game and away from the organization that he shared a once-glorious, now-acrimonious relationship. Where the future of the Green Bay Packers in Aaron Rodgers becomes the present, its past moves on to a team that for various reasons has never grabbed the attention of the country’s biggest market.

In the business of cynics and critics, many have asked if Favre knew what he was getting into. Favre actually admitted that much in his introductory press conference last week:
"I haven't faced anything like this. I don't know anyone in this locker room. To a certain degree, I really don't know what I'm getting into."
While he referred mostly to his new teammates, anyone with a sports pulse in this city may have been thinking about the hornet’s nest that this place can be when a player slips up. Considering that no one has ever batted 1.000, had the 158.3 passer rating, shot 100% from the field or scored a goal in every period of a hockey game in a season, Mr. Favre will be booed for an errant pass at some point this year. However, in the face of the doom-and-gloom predictions for Favre himself, he’ll be fine.

If you haven’t heard, he’s pretty deft with dealing with the media and as it has been known for years, he has a few die hard fans in the press box and broadcasting booth. He also knows what it means to be the signal-caller for a high-profile team. Despite playing in a town whose population is almost one-fourth of that of Staten Island (no joke), Green Bay is home to one of the few franchises in American sports that enjoys a national following. So in terms of playing in the NYC metro area, Favre has a unique perspective compared to other major stars that have come here. The bright lights are nothing new to him, even if those who shine them here are far quicker to highlight something wrong than elsewhere.

As for him knowing the playbook and getting to know his new teammates, this is also something that while it will take some time, he will be in sync with them sooner than later. He’s an unknown to some of these players already because they have gone through the trenches with Chad Pennington and Kellen Clemens for a couple of years now. He’s a complete unknown to the team’s biggest free agent acquisitions, offensive linemen Damien Woody and Alan Faneca. Woody split his first seven seasons with New England and Detroit, having protected Tom Brady for four and a rotation of QBs in the Motor City. Faneca left Pittsburgh after ten seasons blocking for Kordell Stewart, Charlie Batch, Tommy Maddox and Ben Roethlisberger, but giving Jerome Bettis, Deuce Staley and Willie Parker major holes to run through. With the emergence of D’Brickashaw Ferguson and Nick Mangold, the improved line will give Favre and running back Thomas Jones the time they need to execute on offense. He’ll develop chemistry with Lavernues Coles and Jerricho Cotchery over the coming weeks. The vastly underrated fullback Tony Richardson has laid down major hits for various runners and gunslingers in his thirteen-year career. Whoever would have been the quarterback of this team before Favre’s arrival would have found success, albeit with shorter passes and trying to win the time of possession battle. With Favre, the team will be able to test secondaries with deep routes, though the counter on his 288 interceptions will keep clicking for sure. Favre will be fine under center for New York. The light may not come on until late September considering how much time he has missed since the unretirement saga began. Offense is not so much of a concern as defense should be.

Team management traded LB Jonathan Vilma to New Orleans and Dewayne Robinson to Denver in order to bring in players the felt would suit their 3-4 scheme (three down linemen, four linebackers) better. Nose tackle Kris Jenkins and linebacker Calvin Pace were signed in return, and with Shaun Ellis and Kerry Rhodes being the team’s best defenders, the Jets hope that they can emulate the New England Patriots with a defense that relies more on confusing the opponent than physically overwhelming them. That said, they may have been the ninth-best defense against the pass, but they were horrendous against the run (29th of all 32 teams). Much of this can be traced to being on the field too long because the Jets’ offense sputtered so much. However, this coming season finds them facing upper-echelon backs (San Diego’s LaDanian Tomlinson, Cincinnati’s Rudi Johnson, St. Louis’ Steven Jackson and San Francisco’s Frank Gore), teams with two very good backs (Miami, Oakland), a New England team that runs when they need to with Laurence Maroney and a Denver team with an offensive line that always leads the way for out-of-nowhere 1,000-yard runners. Teams know that to beat the Jets, they have to put pressure on their offense and constantly run on their defense.

What should also prevent fans from printing Super Bowl t-shirts for these Jets is that in they will have to fight at least four other teams for what could be just one playoff spot. Besides the Jets, there are eleven legitimate playoff contenders (only Oakland, Kansas City, Baltimore and Miami seem to be in complete rebuilding mode). Contrary to popular belief, Favre cannot be the sole reason why the Jets can eclipse last year’s Wild Card team’s (Tennessee and Jacksonville) or teams that just missed the postseason (Cleveland and Buffalo).

You can argue that the Packers were the most complete team in the NFL last season with a great offensive line, solid wide receivers, unexpected fortunes with Ryan Grant as the running back and a talented defense that had the desired mix of speed and power. Favre may have made a drastic turnaround from two seasons of sub-par football (29 picks in 2005 and 18 in 2006) and heard a few calls to hang up the cleats, yet he got within a game of the Super Bowl because of an elite defense and a very timely discovery of a running game.

Those will be the same factors that determine if he’ll get closer to another one or if he’ll break out the hunting rifle back home after the December 28th finale against Miami.

Wednesday, July 23, 2008

Apprenticeship

You’ve wanted football talk? You got it!



Early this evening on ESPNews, Michelle Bonner moderated her nightly roundtable discussion; this evening bringing about the latest chapter in the Brett Favre saga. Unanimously, these three sports talkies said that the Green Bay Packers – the team that Favre and others (including Reggie White) brought back from the dead –should do everything possible to not only bring him back, but to delay the development of Aaron Rodgers for another season by returning the future Hall of Famer to his starting role.



One of the talkies (whose name doesn’t come to memory at the moment) said that having Rodgers, the fourth-year quarterback from California, wait out another season as Favre returns would be similar to a scenario played out in San Francisco in the early 90s: when Steve Young waited for his time to shine behind Joe Montana. Again, unanimously, all pointed to the sudden fortunes for the 49ers once Young took over behind center. Not only did he add the franchise’s fifth Super Bowl title after the 1994 season, but won the league’s MVP award twice, led the league in passing rating six times, was selected to the Pro Bowl seven times and was enshrined in the Hall of Fame three years ago.



While it’s all well and good (and this Scribe will freely admit to Young being the personal favorite signal-caller of all time), the logic that these apprenticeships are similar is a bit off.



Way off.

For starters, let’s look at how the Montana-Young combination was created in the first place. Young, whose success at BYU led him to becoming one of the major signings for the short-lived USFL, had bombed out with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. When the Bucs drafted Vinny Testaverde in 1987, Young was traded to San Francisco for the Niners’ second- and fourth-round draft picks.



For four seasons from 1987-1990, Young served as Montana’s backup, but with various injuries to #16, the scrambling leftie had some significant playing time. As the number 2 QB, Young threw 23 touchdowns to just six interceptions. In the 1989 season where Montana won his second league MVP and fourth Super Bowl, Young still amassed 1,001 yards, eight TDs and just 3 picks.



With Montana having missed the 1992 season due to an elbow injury suffered in the ’91 NFC title game, Young was the undisputed starter. When Young himself was erratic or injured, he was replaced by another Steve, this one being Bono. Bono played well enough in a few games that season that it warranted some discussion on not only who should be the starting signal caller, but how much better the team performed with Montana. Though Montana was returning to full strength, he was unable to do so for the start of 1992 season, allowing Young to hold on to the starting role. It was a blessing in disguise as #8 overcame another show start to take home his first MVP award, first Pro Bowl and first playoff appearance (defeating Washington, but losing to Dallas in the NFC Championship). This gave the front office the confidence to stick with Young by trading Montana to Kansas City before the 1993 campaign.



Of course, Young exceeded everyone’s expectations by not only winning another MVP and a Super Bowl of his own, but carved his own legacy in the Bay Area.


The situation is much different for Rodgers. Unlike Young, who entered the league with collegiate and USFL brilliance to be humbled in his first few years in the NFL, Rodgers’ success in California was scrutinized heavily from the moment his NCAA career ended. As discussed previously, it was essentially a coin flip between him and Utah’s Alex Smith, by none other than… the lusterless San Francisco 49ers. Once the Niners chose Smith with the top overall pick in 2005, he was passed over by twenty teams whose immediate need was not at the quarterback position. Instead, he was selected to reside on Green Bay’s bench until the last whim of Favre would lead him to retirement.



Yet, Favre’s record streak of 275 consecutive starts under center (253 regular season and 22 playoffs) proved that he still had something in that right arm.



Favre, for all of his grit and toughness, was fortunate to never have endured an injury that would sideline him for a significant amount of time (or at all, actually). Yet, Rodgers found significant playing time in one of the mere six games Favre had been unable to finish in his career. After just throwing 35 passes (completing fifteen for 46 yards and one pick), Rodgers had a stellar backup effort in a 37-27 loss in Dallas last fall. In 2 ½ quarters of play, he went 18-for-26 with 201 yards and his first touchdown toss. While he was sacked three times, it gave Packers management a better idea of how their potential heir apparent could perform when the game still matters.



The moment that Favre announced his farewell in March, rumors and prayers were abound in hopes that he would not file his retirement papers. Green Bay, having gone through Favre’s flirtations with retirement for years, seemed to be poised to finally let Rodgers lead the team. Despite reaching the NFC title game last season, it appeared as if management was willing to let him take the reins with what is arguably the most complete starting roster in the NFL.



Whether Rodgers turns out to be a flop or first-ballot Hall of Famer in his own right remains to be seen. There are a few active quarterbacks who had to wait longer than others before becoming The Man for their franchises, such as Seattle’s Matt Hasselbeck (a former Favre backup), Houston’s Matt Schaub, San Diego’s Philip Rivers and Jacksonville’s David Garrard. While none had to ‘wait for the old man to retire’, they have proven to have the goods to win in the NFL (though Hasselbeck and Schaub had to be traded for their chances). Rodgers could be the next to join this group.



As Young watched Montana nearly twenty years earlier, Rodgers must have learned a ton by observing Favre, albeit with reluctance and anxiousness. As Young, he spent a few years understanding the exacting West Coast offense with a clipboard, practices, preseason games and mop-up duty. As Young, he came to a team that while loaded with emerging talent that could contend for titles in the future, it was anticipating the sunset on a legend that could have gave them at least one. Yet, the common thread ends there.



Injuries set the wheels in motion for Steve Young to supplant Joe Montana. Competitiveness and/or stubbornness of Brett Favre could be keeping Aaron Rodgers in limbo.



And maybe the Green Bay Packers’ future.



Say What?!?!: Well, if the Pack is serious about moving forward with Rodgers, they might want to take off Favre from that current players' masthead on the team website.

Tuesday, March 4, 2008

Finally!

He must have learned a ton from watching along the sidelines.

He must have taken every practice snap asked of him.

He must have watched more film than he ever planned to.

Yet, no matter how cordial or cool the relationship may have been between the long-time lead and the prodigious understudy - no one outside of the organization really knows - deep down, this has to be the happiest man on Earth thanks to the retirement of no. 4.



You might remember reading about him somewhere...

Monday, December 17, 2007

Unknown

Doug Pederson had five touchdown passes and 398 passing yards for Green Bay. That is a career game if there wasn’t one.

But, it was his career as a Packer. Pederson completed 46 of 77 passes in two stints as Brett Favre’s backup in 1998 and from 2001-2004. In his time, he served as a player-coach, mostly advising Favre on his throws and reading opposing defenses from the sidelines. Though he had also warmed the seat in Philadelphia for Donovan McNabb and in Cleveland for Tim Couch, Pederson was not what you’d call a starting quarterback. It didn’t help that he backed up a Hall-of-Famer-in-waiting that hasn’t thought of retiring. Eventually, Favre was going to leave the game and Pederson, himself, was not a spring chicken.

Meanwhile, another franchise played the transition game in much more drastic and painful ways. The San Francisco 49ers have been identified by the West Coast Offense and the men who ran it; head coach Bill Walsh and his quarterbacks. Joe Montana and Steve Young became Hall-of-Famers while in the post-Walsh era, Jeff Garcia became a Pro Bowl quarterback in the system. Unfortunately for the Niner Faithful, the organization has endured multiple setbacks as a result of penalties from Eddie DeBartolo Jr.’s implications in a corruption scandal, a shift in ownership and unwise personnel moves. Enter new head coach Mike Nolan in January 2005 along with the number one pick in the ensuing NFL Draft.

Of course, this was a Draft in which the most impactful quarterback in the league was a sixth round selection by the Baltimore Ravens. That’s Cleveland’s Derek Anderson.

Huh?

San Francisco had decided to hone in on selecting a young signal-caller as opposed to giving capable QB Tim Rattay a chance to call the offense his own. So they were trying to decide between Alex Smith of Utah and California’s Aaron Rodgers. Smith had the advantage of graduating in three years while mastering Urban Meyer’s spread option offense (one that the coach took with him to Florida). He had thrown for nearly 3,000 yards and ran for an additional 653 in his final season with the Utes, a 12-0 season capped by beating FSU in the Fiesta Bowl. In a year where future Arizona Cardinals QB Matt Leinart was the talk of college football for the USC Trojans, Smith was still relatively unfamiliar to the nation at-large because Utah had never been discussed in the pantheon of collegiate powers.

In the Niners’ backyard, Rodgers had been under center for a Golden Bears team that ranked as high as fourth in the nation in his last season at Berkeley. He only garnered interest from Illinois coming out of high school, but as a walk-on. He chose to go through Butte College, a junior college near his hometown, in order to earn a Division I scholarship through transfer. When Cal and head coach Jeff Tedford came calling, the move paid off as he became a starter by the fifth game of the next season. While he threw for more yards in 2003 (2905), his efficiency under Tedford’s tutelage made him a commodity in 2004 as he threw just seven picks to 23 touchdowns.

If Leinart decided to put his name in the Draft, San Francisco may have not been so torn between the two. However, he decided to try to win a third national championship.


Smith was chosen by the Niners based on the ability to absorb information quickly, one of the principal traits coaches expect from their offensive captains. He didn’t just graduate in three years, but he graduated with an economics degree, nonetheless. Coming from a graduate of an all-business college who almost failed an economics class, that’s a pretty impressive feat. As previously mentioned, Smith was also a mobile quarterback who was capable of buying himself time or moving the ball downfield on his own if his options were limited. With the 49ers still working with the West Coast Offense, Smith was to add his running abilities in the way that Young and Garcia had done throughout the 1990s and early part of this decade. When Rattay was traded to Tampa Bay early in the 2005 season, it made a clear path for Smith to become the starter. Eventually, every high-profiled rookie has to take his lumps.

Did anyone expect for those lumps to include eleven interceptions to just one touchdown (and I was there for that touchdown, by the way)? Doubt it.

His second season saw the addition of a new offensive coordinator (Norv Turner), a new tight end (Vernon Davis) and a new backfield (Frank Gore becoming the every down back with Michael Robinson and Maurice Hicks splitting some carries). Smith made marked improvements under Turner’s tutelage, throwing 16 touchdowns to just as many interceptions while passing on the run with play-action fakes and rolling out from the pocket. Despite the departure of Turner to replace Marty Schottenheimer in San Diego, the Niners were the chic pick to be the young team that would make the playoffs in a muddled NFC. The playmakers were there, ownership spent money to fix the defense and the confidence of improving over the past two seasons was going to buoy the team back into the postseason.


On the other side of this coin, Rodgers found himself slipping further and further from where draft experts pegged him. San Francisco passed on Rodgers more so because of what they saw with Smith rather than something Rodgers may have lacked. There has also been a poor track record of Tedford-coached quarterbacks in the first round (Kyle Boller, Trent Dilfer, Joey Harrington and Akili Smith). The real reason for the freefall in the draft was that most of the teams after the Niners didn’t feel that getting a quarterback was the priority in the first round. After twenty two more teams passed up on him, Green Bay scooped him up. It became serious business as the Packers seemed to acknowledge the reality of Favre’s eventual retirement. Of course, Favre didn’t leave.

Rodgers saw some time in a couple of late season games during the Pack’s 4-12 campaign in 2005. When Favre held the position in limbo while trying to decide if he would call it quits, Rodgers may have wanted to play, but there were rumblings about him not capable of handling the offense at the time. Of course, Favre didn’t leave.

While filling in for an injured Favre during a thumping by New England, Rodgers broke his foot in, putting him on injured reserve for the rest of 2006. In the ensuing offseason, his name was thrown around in a trade rumor to bring Randy Moss to Green Bay. When that didn’t materialize, Moss went to the Patriots and Rodgers found his trusty clipboard. Again, Favre didn’t leave.

To describe this season for both quarterbacks is to describe the epitome of frustration. Smith separated his shoulder when being sacked in a game against Seattle, and despite trying to come back later in the season, he had to be shut down for the remainder of the year. To make matters worse, Smith wasn’t very good when he was healthy enough to play. In addition to having his third different offensive coordinator, Gore has been bottled up for much of the season, Davis has been ineffective and the wide receivers have been underwhelming. What was going to be a banner year in the Bay turned sour when September became October. As for Rodgers, he filled in for Favre once again a few weeks ago against Dallas. In his first significant time under center, he played well enough to whittle a 17-point Cowboys lead to three points, yet Dallas’ three sacks and constant pressure gave them the win. Favre returned the next game and has kept the team rolling towards a first-round bye in the playoffs. Being part of the team headed to the postseason must be a reward in itself, but Rodgers must be stir-crazy about ‘the old guy’ keeping him on the bench.

From Vallejo to Milpitas and throughout the Bay Area, fans and media have been rather critical of Smith. Many have already labeled him a bust. While he hasn’t made life easier by being tentative to make plays with his legs as he did under Turner, he has had three different offensive coordinators and ineffective players outside of Gore. The 49ers have made significant financial commitments to him, so he’s not going away anytime soon. However, the desire to tweak the formula won’t change either. Next season, he may have a fourth play-caller and he has to recover from surgery to the shoulder. Next season may also see Rodgers sitting on the sidelines again, as Favre’s future is going to be linked to the Packers’ postseason success. Maybe he became a commodity for teams that may look for a new direction for 2008. Maybe he’ll be the hot backup QB like Matt Schaub was for Atlanta. Or maybe, he becomes Doug Pederson. Just as much can be said about Eli Manning and Philip Rivers after four years, it’ll take four years to know what both teams would be able to do with Smith and Rodgers.

If they’re ready to find out.

Say What?!?!: Snow can be fun. Watching football can be just as fun. And for those of you that love alcohol, a drink here and there is a good time for you all. The combination of the three? Not so much. While covering the Redskins-Giants game last night, a few ‘geniuses’ thought it would be a good idea to throw snowballs onto the field. Later in the game, one of Washington’s players was hit with something a little more than snow (try ice), forcing him to double over for a moment. This also occurred in Foxborough during the Jets-Patriots game. When the public address announcer has to tell and remind fans to not hurl anything onto the field, that’s not very good. In fact, that’s downright asinine. We all can be displeased with a team’s effort or a bad call by the referee, but to use the elements as an excuse to make it known is beyond childish. It might seem funny; it might get you a nice urban legend. It will also make you the new millennium’s Jeffrey Lange. Readers of Scribe are smart folks, so I trust that you would never be so stupid.